February 2014

The Brown Center on Education Policy at Brookings released two papers examining pension reform efforts across the nation. A presentation of the papers’ findings and a panel discussion followed. Read our picks for the best live tweets in response to the discussion.

Just as teachers in Missouri cannot move between pension boundaries without incurring a financial penalty, teachers cannot move across state pension boundaries without incurring similar costs. This acts like a tariff that restricts the movement of human capital between pension systems.
As Chicago's pension funding is falling, the average teacher retirement benefit is rising. Not only do the retirement benefits come with an expensive price tag, but they're back-loaded for late-career teachers such that only a small percentage of teachers will receive a pension benefit in the first place.
There's something broken about New York City's teacher dismissal process.
To ensure the accuracy of pension plan assumptions, state retirement systems conduct regular “experience studies” to compare their assumptions with data about the actual numbers observed on the ground. Experience studies help ensure the accuracy of a plan by measuring any fluctuations in the field and proposing subsequent adjustments to plan assumptions. We unearthed over two decades worth of experience studies from North Dakota.
The unpredictable nature of pension contributions has a real consequence on school district budgets and, therefore, on teachers.
Alexander Volokh argues that the California Rule protecting government-worker pensions is legally permissible, but should be rejected nonetheless as a matter of policy.
Two simple graphs show show that current teachers in Kansas City and St. Louis are poorly served by their defined benefit pension plans.
Media sources often cite the average teacher pension, using it as a pivotal talking point for showing benefits as either overly generous or overly stingy. However, averages can be deceptive. The average often includes outliers on both extremes, creating a narrow picture of the pension distribution.