Public- and private-sector workers’ retirements used to be structured similarly. Not that long ago, both groups were likely to have access to defined benefit pension plans that guaranteed monthly payments until death. Both sets of workers retired at about the same ages.
These things have changed over the last 25 years as private-sector employers have abandoned DB plans, private-sector workers have been retiring at older ages, and public-sector workers, including teachers, have been retiring younger. By 2009, only one in five private-sector workers had access to a DB plan, compared to 89 percent of teachers and 84 percent of all state and local government employees who are still enrolled in one.
People make retirement decisions for all sorts of reasons. Maybe they have grandchildren they want to spend time with, or a hobby they want to develop. People also base their retirement decisions on both the amount and the structure of their retirement benefits. Even after controlling for total wealth, the security offered by DB plans–those guaranteed monthly payments until death–lead people to retire 1-2 years earlier than they would with 401k plans. Because of the generosity and the structure of their retirement plans, teachers now retire more than four years younger than private-sector workers.
This divergence didn’t always exist, but it’s becoming a real problem. The workers at companies that used to offer DB plans but now only have access to less-secure 401ks are not likely to tolerate this imbalance forever. The Wall Street Journal is reporting that many employers who cut their matching contributions during the Great Recession have been slow to reinstate them, which will only make the problem more pronounced. Teachers and other public workers have long traded lower base salaries for better benefits and more security, but that dichotomy has become more obvious and more important. Taxpayers may not continue to look kindly on generous teacher and government-worker retirement plans as their own are being cut.
This blog entry first appeared on The Quick and the Ed.